The recent general elections in France provided a sigh of relief for many Europeans concerned about the rise of far-right governments within the European Union (EU). However, the specter of far-right influence remains a potent force across the continent. What is the factors contributing to the far-right surge in Europe, its implications for EU immigration policies, and the consequential rise in Islamophobia.
The Rise of the Far Right: Traditional Explanations
Economic Factors
Historically, the rise of populism in Europe has often been linked to economic turmoil. A decade ago, Europe was grappling with a debt crisis, leading to widespread austerity measures, high unemployment, and economic recession. During this period, both left and right-wing populist parties gained significant traction, capitalizing on public dissatisfaction. However, the current economic landscape offers a different picture. Despite inflation concerns, Europe enjoys record-high employment and significant public investment following the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine. This diminishes the explanatory power of economic hardship in the contemporary rise of the far-right.
Greenlash and Climate Policies
Another contributing factor is the so-called “greenlash,” a backlash against stringent climate policies. Measures such as taxes on petrol, reduction of agricultural subsidies, and higher energy costs have sparked protests, particularly among farmers. This discontent played a crucial role in the recent electoral success of Geert Wilders in the Netherlands. Nonetheless, the transition to renewable energy has also brought tangible benefits, such as reduced energy costs and government-sponsored subsidies for energy efficiency, complicating the greenlash narrative.
Migration and Cultural Homogeneity
Migration remains a hot-button issue often cited in the rise of far-right politics. The influx of migrants is perceived by some as a threat to cultural homogeneity, fueling xenophobia and nationalist sentiments. However, the relationship between migration and far-right support is not straightforward. Far-right parties tend to perform poorly in cosmopolitan cities with high migrant populations, such as London, Paris, and Milan. Conversely, they gain traction in rural and provincial areas with minimal migrant presence. Additionally, despite fears of job competition, high employment levels have muted the narrative of “migrants stealing jobs.” Even right-wing governments, like Italy’s under Giorgia Meloni, are increasing work visas for foreign workers to address labor shortages.
- Transforming Europe: The Rise of Leftists and Reformers
- Ukraine to Kashmir: Could Europe Spark the Next World War?
- Rethinking the European Global Strategy and the role of think tanks
A Deeper Dive: Nationalism and Europe’s Decline
The Psychological Impact of Relative Decline
To fully grasp the rise of the far-right, one must consider the psychological impact of Europe’s perceived decline on the global stage. Renowned philosopher Hannah Arendt highlighted how Europe’s imperial past helped reconcile internal inequalities by uniting different social classes through a shared sense of superiority over colonized peoples. In the contemporary context, Europe’s marginalization, technological lag, and geopolitical disorientation have triggered a resurgence of nationalism. This nationalism is not expansionist but rather a defensive reaction to perceived decline and disorientation.
Nationalism as a Refuge
The far-right capitalizes on these sentiments by promoting the nation as a sanctuary of cohesion, unity, and shared purpose. This brand of nationalism seeks to forge a sense of community by defining itself against perceived “others,” such as migrants, minorities, and progressive social movements. This strategy of exclusion helps create a false but compelling sense of unity and purpose amidst widespread fear and anxiety.
The Impact on EU Immigration Policies
Stricter Immigration Controls
The rise of the far-right has significant implications for EU immigration policies. Far-right parties typically advocate for stricter immigration controls, tighter border security, and more stringent asylum policies. These measures can lead to reduced immigration flows, increased deportations, and harsher living conditions for migrants and asylum seekers.
Islamophobia and Discrimination
The far-right’s anti-immigration stance is often intertwined with Islamophobia, leading to increased discrimination and hostility towards Muslim communities. Islamophobic rhetoric and policies contribute to a climate of fear and mistrust, further marginalizing Muslim immigrants and exacerbating social tensions. This can manifest in various forms, including hate crimes, workplace discrimination, and exclusion from public services and opportunities.
The Broader Impact on European Society
Erosion of Multiculturalism
The far-right’s rise threatens the multicultural fabric of European society. Policies aimed at curbing immigration and promoting cultural homogeneity undermine efforts to build inclusive and diverse communities. This erosion of multiculturalism can have long-term social and economic consequences, including decreased innovation, reduced cultural exchange, and heightened social fragmentation.
Political Polarization
The far-right’s ascent also contributes to increased political polarization, as mainstream parties and progressive movements mobilize against xenophobic and nationalist agendas. This polarization can lead to legislative gridlock, hinder effective governance, and destabilize political systems. It also poses a challenge to the EU’s unity, as member states grapple with divergent views on immigration and national identity.
Complex phenomenon
The surge of the far-right in Europe is a complex phenomenon driven by a mix of economic, social, and psychological factors. While traditional explanations such as economic hardship and migration concerns play a role, the deeper driver is a pervasive sense of national decline and disorientation. The far-right’s rise has profound implications for EU immigration policies and the rise of Islamophobia, posing significant challenges to the continent’s multiculturalism and political stability. As Europe navigates this uncertain future, it must address the underlying causes of nationalist sentiment while fostering inclusive and cohesive societies.
References
- Al Jazeera. “Europe’s far right and the impact of immigration.” Available at: Al Jazeera
- BBC News. “Analysis: The rise of nationalism in Europe.” Available at: BBC News
- The Guardian. “Far-right politics and Europe’s response.” Available at: The Guardian
- Reuters. “Impact of far-right policies on EU immigration.” Available at: Reuters
- The New York Times. “Islamophobia and the far-right surge in Europe.” Available at: NY Times
